CristinaM.

Assessing Kids’ Blogs, Or How It Becomes Another Assignment

In Uncategorized on January 3, 2012 at 10:33 am

It has been a week full of memes and tagging teachers and lessons on how blogs written by children should be evaluated. Honestly, I am tired of that. And of course, I am against it.

Firstly, we should ask ourselves these questions:

1.      What is the purpose of student blogging?

2.      What are the reasons for assessing them?

3.      If assessing, how can you develop a rubric that covers creativity/round pegs in square holes?

 Since I do not have the same teaching values as everyone else (thank god for diversity!) I can only express my own views and share my own classroom practices.

Blog

1.      Purpose: My students do not blog to showcase their “best work” as others do. They blog to tell me about many things:

          how they learned to play an instrument

          who came to visit and what they did together

          what criteria they would use for a final project

          what ideas they have for the current inquiry unit (yes, I ask for their input so some lessons are done together, based on their views)

          how they liked Skyping with a teacher

          what their reaction is in relation to a lesson, a video that I or their peers posted

          what application they discovered and how we can use it in class

          what their questions are about a specific topic

          to tell me what they are doing while they are ill, at home

and so much more.

Some write more, others less.

Some write nearly daily, others less frequently.

Some have more spelling mistakes (we are second-language learners), others none.

Some use pictures or videos or embed an app (e.g. VoiceThread), others don’t.

 

Conclusion: Our class blog transfers the idea of community and need for self-expression. It is not yet another assignment that has to be done.

That I encourage them to blog is one thing, but to make them accountable for not blogging enough or according to certain criteria is another. It is, eventually, a personal choice. Don’t WE blog when and if we want to?…

 

2.      Reasons for assessing students can be found at anytime, right? It is in our culture to judge and set kids against criteria (and often against each other – of course, under the surface). But then, I ask, why would anyone blog if they found themselves rated and judged all the time? I asked today on Twitter, “ Would you like to be evaluated based on a rubric”? It would be interesting to see who would.

 

3.      Now the famous rubric.  We can develop a 10, 20 –point rubric covering a lot of what one should look in a blog for: language, style, mechanics, multimedia etc. Sure we can do that – we are teachers. We can turn nearly everything into measurable scales. But…just take a look at the diversity of blogs out there. Most would inevitably  fail.

The first example that comes to mind is Seth Godin who has thousands of readers. Multimedia? None. Does it have a classical rigorous structure? Not at all. Length? Not even that – his blog posts are some of the shortest on the web. No, Seth, you wouldn’t get maximum of points on my rubric- sorry to disappoint you.

 

Other examples? John Hagel. Oh boy, he blogs very rarely and his posts…well, loooooooooooong. Really long and always packed with so many ideas to munch on. You always need to reread them and rethink. But oops, no multimedia there. Just plain, articulated, good writing. Sorry for you, John, but neither you will make the 100% on my rubric.

 

And the list can go on.

So here I am asking: how can a rubric cover this creative, very personal style of blogging? It can’t, in my opinion. Because a rubric also excludes. What is new, interesting and relevant in other ways.

 

For me, not only in regard to blogging but to teaching in general, this Indian saying  tells quite a lot: “If we want to make the elephant grow, we feed him, not weigh him every day.”  Let the children write, offer them models, let them engage in conversations – with peers, you, others – and allow them this freedom. Because eventually they would blog better. And better.

 *Because J. in the comments asked, I thought of providing a visual proof of how comments change in time without any rubric whatsoever. Feedback and conversations is all it takes for kids to get better – the same way we, as adults, improve.

 

Blogging
  1. I’ve heard a version of the elephant metaphor before, about fattening a cow by leaving her in the field. They’re obvious, and powerful. I always imagine a little plant trying to grow but being dug up every day to see how the roots are developing. Traumatic, to say the least.

  2. I think that word conveys very well what we sometimes do to kids with this emphasis on assessment: "traumatic". Thank you for reading, as always, David. One of the unique blogs I mentioned a while ago was yours, too (see here http://www.twitlonger.com/show/evihb5 ).

  3. Brilliant!!Cristina, you rock so much! I always have a big smile on my face when I read you blog.Please don’t hesitate to ask me if the little ones would benefit from another skype chat, or if there’s a unit of inquiry I could somehow contribute to.BestWilly

  4. The kids would love to Skype again with you, Willy! They asked me, now and then, about you so i had to show them your Twitter profile. :)You could read-aloud to them http://read-aloudwiththeworld.wikispaces.com/ and maybe contribute to the unit The Write Stuff (we’ll be inquiring into writing).Thank you for the comment!

  5. Hi CristinaThis was an interesting article to read as I contemplate starting blogging with my new class this year. I can see your point, I don’t think a rubric really needs to be in place to evaluate a student’s blog. It seems a bit over the top. As like any assessment, they would probably benefit much more from some ongoing specific feedback. Have you blogged with your students before? If so, what do you think are the important components of guiding students towards quality blogging and comments?ThanksJarrydMrheyjteacher.wordpress.com

  6. Hi J.,My students have beeen blogging since second grade. The only way they improved was by receving feedback both from me and from their peers – which occured spontaneouly. How I guided them? I just asked them to see what blog comments they liked and what they liked about those comments. They realized what a quality comment looks like just by interacting with one another and reading different types of comments – either from our class blog or from others. The fact that you do not assess learning outcomes through a rubric doesn’t mean lerning does not take place. We, as adults, improve all the time without any rubric whatsoever, just by simply conversing and receving feedback from others.Please see the sample I attached to the blog post.

  7. <a rel="new tab" href="http://www.kindergluck.com">Reading comprehension worksheets for kids</a>

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: